Pagley's Pasta & More menu

Pagley's Pasta & More brings classic Italian comfort food to New Castle in an easygoing, family-friendly setting. Nestled in the heart of the community, this restaurant has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The menu showcases a variety of Italian dishes, including pasta, pizza, wings, sandwiches, and hearty dinners. The restaurant takes pride in its generous portions, homemade pasta, and rich, flavorful sauces. The bar side of the restaurant is newer and beautiful, while the old part maintains its classic charm. Great cocktails, a kids' menu, vegetarian options, and patio seating accommodate a wide range of guests.

The menu at Pagley's Pasta & More is thoughtfully structured to satisfy both traditionalists and adventurous palates. For those seeking the signature experience, the Homemade Ravioli is a standout — described as "unbelievably big and delicious". The Chicken Parmigiana is a guest favorite, praised for its crispy exterior and tender, juicy meat. The Spaghetti and Meatballs delivers classic comfort with homemade sauce that tastes like it came straight from Italy. The Shrimp Scampi offers a more adventurous option, while the 12-cut pizza with meatballs has been called absolutely delicious. For those seeking something different, the Portobello Mushroom Steak Sandwich is a customer favorite.

Appetizers and sides round out the dining experience. The Fried Calamari has earned a loyal following, with even young diners loving it. The Chicken Pastina Soup and Wedding Soup offer warm, comforting starters. Beans and Greens with Sausage provides a hearty, flavorful side. For dessert, guests can enjoy classic Italian sweets. The restaurant also offers vegetarian options, including various pasta dishes.

Service options: Outdoor patio seating, dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Great cocktails, kids' menu, and vegetarian options available. High chairs provided. Wheelchair accessible.

Pagley's Pasta & More invites guests to enjoy generous portions of homemade Italian classics, from unforgettable ravioli to crispy chicken parmesan, in a warm, welcoming New Castle setting.