Pagley's Pasta & More sits in New Castle, the area, with a family-friendly room that greets you before the first plate arrives. The neighborhood sets a slower rhythm, and a cozy dining room makes it feel like a place people return to on purpose.
Come hungry for pizza. Follow with pasta if you are sharing, and keep the kitchen's daily strengths in mind when the table wants one more plate.
Small courtesies matter here: a clear recommendation, a topped-up water glass, a table that does not feel flipped. Weeknights usually run quieter than weekends. The listing address is 1235 E Washington St, New Castle, PA 16101.
Save Pagley's Pasta & More when you want New Castle dining without the noise of rankings - just pizza and a table that behaves like it belongs to the block.
Before you visit, skim recent neighbor notes on the listing and confirm hours on the door. Platefolk keeps this page as a field guide, not a frozen brochure - the best proof is still sitting down for a meal.
What we value here is consistency: a kitchen that repeats its strengths, a room that does not treat guests like tickets, and a Pagley's Pasta & More visit that still feels worth the trip across town. Bring curiosity, order something the staff recommends, and leave a short note afterward so the next diner arrives wiser.
in love with the ravioli and chicken pastene but didn’t get pictures of both come here every other week staff is nothing but friendly and amazing! All the girls make you feel at home! I’d definitely try it if you haven’t
All their food is very good, but the ravioli is unbelievable. It’s so big and so good. Please don’t ever stop making that.that’s a great dish. They used to have the smelt. I wish they would bring that back.
While I have to say the food quality and food was 5 star. The steak was Delicious but the staff and service all the way a round was different.
Food is good, but that’s it. It’s hard to get them to answer the phone to place a takeout order, your food is never ready on time, your order is ALWAYS missing items and the owner is extremely rude. The bad experiences far outweigh the good.
This place is amazing you couldn't ask for a better Italian restaurant. My 8-year-old absolutely loves the calamari. She gets it anytime and every time we go there. This is one of my mom and pop's favorite places to go to eat after church. The staff are always amazing
I live out of town and have been craving Pagley’s, so tonight I bought dinner for my family. I was SO disappointed in the quality of food that I honestly will never order here again. My fettuccini alfredo was bland, the chicken was hard and dry, and the salad was completely inedible. My salad was brown and my sister found black pieces of lettuce in hers. This meal was definitely not worth the $70 I spent. My mom liked her raviolis, which is the only reason I’m giving it 2 stars.
Excellent food and atmosphere! Quick & friendly service!
Thank you! Your review has been submitted for moderation.
